OK - follow-up to the last post: the machine is back up. However, lots of hassle and problems ensued. Every time I tried to reload Windows came up with a new challenge and failure. I finally bought a new hard drive since the MBR seemed to be getting roached every time this thing crashed. I had even gotten to the point that a fresh install of Windows (on the new hard drive, no less) required a 'Reload/Repair' just to get to the desktop. This was after setting all of the BIOS settings to 'Default.' Still had issues once it did finally get to the desktop - it was acting like it had 64MB of PC-100 RAM in it - and took 3 hours just to install the chipset drivers before it finally froze up and crashed for the last time.
I jumped on Newegg.com and ordered a new motherboard - an MSI K9A2GM-FIH to replace the one in there now.
Then today, after poking around on AnandTech forums, I decided to do some research on the RAM I'd recently bought to solve these issues. Turns out that the Crucial Ballistix PC-6400 DDR2 RAM likes to have it's own CAS settings... and the ASUS mobo wasn't quite working with the 'Auto' settings. The RAM likes CAS settings of 4/4/4/12 and 2.0V(olts) of juice. The 'Auto' settings were 5/5/5/18 and 1.8V - well, that'll do it.
Once I manually set the mobo's memory settings to play nice with the RAM, I had an uneventful and successful installation of XP. I even loaded everything back onto the hard drive (I'm going to let BigDawg handle the e-mail for a little while longer) though. I also just played Unreal Tournament 3 for about an hour with nary a skip, stutter, or burp from the machine - and it only warmed up the CPU to 56C... to which it promptly cooled back down to 46C once the game shut off.
I'm not calling this one solved by any means, however I'll give the machine the benefit of doubt for now, since it seems to have begun to behave after tweaking the RAM settings. If it hasn't crashed in a month or so, then I'll press on with my tech-refresh/migration project. I'm also beginning to wonder if the RAM settings would've allowed the Kingston ValueRAM I originally purchased to run as well. Who knows.
Now, I guess I just need to get another CPU and an optical drive, and I can build yet another machine with the new mobo, RAM, hard drive, and case I won't be using as a result of this project.
This is one of those annoying things I do for fun. Ever since the guy at Power Systems soaked me for $3200 for a new PC in October '96, I've learned how to build my own. Not to mention, my pal (and Boss at the time) Lewis McBride kinda snapped me into the reality that I was a computer technician, and I shouldn't be afraid to build my own junk. He was right, of course. My other friend Al Peterson (a VMS programmer) helped me over my anxiety of blowing up Windows and making applications work with each other even when they don't see to want to.
I think had I not had those guys influencing me and helping me over the fence (as it were) I wouldn't be as in-touch with my machines as I am now. I'm not fanatical about it or anything, but I do know I've just spent the better part of 16 hours fussing with my new machine getting it to work, rather than admit defeat. In the past, I would've just ordered a new mother board (which I already did, actually) before taking on trying to actually troubleshoot something like what I was up against. I still may need the new mobo, but for now I think I might've actually won this one.
Lewis might even be a little proud of me, if he knew what I've gone through with this new machine.